To horses, a treat is not a bribe unless
you use it as one. I see it as a reward, or payment for a job well done.
It offers incentive for the horse to earn more and they look forward
to their work when payment is forthcoming.
Giving a horse a treat just as that –
you’re thanking them for giving their time to join in with your
games or a job that needs doing.
How many times would we turn up for work
if we didn’t get paid?
Some of us do voluntary work and enjoy praise and recognition as a reward
– something common to predators such as humans and dogs.
Horse however, are prey animals and for
them reward is release of pressure or being left alone altogether, along
with being able to eat. When a horse satisfies its basic requirements
of safety, comfort and play then it wants to eat, so rewarding a horse
with food shows us the horse is relaxed and comfortable about what we’ve
been asking. A tense uptight horse will refuse to eat, even special
treats, when its mind is focusing on survival.
Giving your horse a treat for a job well
done, is a bit like taking your friend out for lunch because you just
love their company or when you want to thank them for something.
We don’t see someone paying for our lunch as a bribe, unless there’s
something seriously wrong with the relationship.
Likewise, we couldn’t expect our
friend to keep turning up to help dig postholes, chop wood or cart hay
if we didn’t give them some sort of treat in return.
Sure, we’d thank them the first time, but unless we gave them
a treat (beers, money, help in return) would they keep coming back for
more hard work?
That’s what we’re asking
of our horses when we train or ride them, time after time.
Giving your horse a treat is a bit like inviting your friend to lunch,
or to stay for a beer and BBQ, or offering your help in return for theirs.
And so it should be with our horses if we want a fair and equitable
relationship.
When horses are fed treats as a reward,
even randomly, they will line up to see who gets to play with their
‘leader’ today. They will offer behaviours they’ve
learned to see if that will earn them some pay, and are keen to learn
new ones to get more pay. 
Some people see giving a horse treats
as dangerous and inviting pushy behaviour.
Of course it will result in that if you haven’t set boundaries
and if your timing is off when giving the treat.
Clicker trainers are the ones to learn
from here – they know how to stop horses mugging them by waiting
for the appropriate behaviour before the food is given.
That behaviour could be backing or turning their head away, or just
staying out of your personal space before the treat is delivered.
Learning how to deliver the treat (and
when to wait), is as important as recognising the behaviour you want
to reward. That’s why clicker people use an audible ‘click’
signal to mark the behaviour – “it says yes that’s
what I want” – and then delivering the small food reward
such as few grains of oats or sunflower seeds or pellets, or tiny cubes
of carrot or apple.
The behaviour the horse does when it
receives the reward is as important as the one it got the click for.
If you allow the horse to thrust its nose into your space and demand
the treat, it will very soon realise this gets it the treat quicker.
That’s when mugging starts. 
All you have to do is wait until the
horse turns its head away, backs up a bit, or lowers it’s head
(whatever behaviour you deem as safe) before giving the treat. Your
horse will then remain respectful of your space and not demand the treat.
In the beginning, especially if you’re
correcting already learned mugging behaviour, its best to position yourself
on the other side of the fence or stall door so you can move out of
reach if the horse persists with mugging. Then just wait – most
likely the horse will quit trying and move away to do something else
or get distracted and look elsewhere, and this is when you can safely
deliver the treat.
They very quickly link their behaviour with food deliverance and will
then offer that readily, to get he treat quicker after you have signalled
a ‘yes’.
All my horses have had some basic ‘clicker
training’ to help with their respect around food and treats.
As they receive these randomly, but reasonably often, they remain keen
and interested in coming when called, being haltered or going to do
something.
They are happy to be rewarded for hoof trimming at liberty, going on
the horse float or at the end of a ride.
I believe it’s important to ask
“What’s in it for them” – and to enhance the
release of pressure with a reward (food or itching them) so your relationship
is one of love and fun for both of you.
PS - Feed treats from your horse's regular
grain ration (so you don't overfeed) but if your horse is overweight
or prone to laminitis, the safest treat is sunflower seeds which are
low in sugar. Carrots are very high in sugar so only use them as 'jackpot'
treats every once in a while.
GIVING
HORSES CHOICES- The beautiful Boronia.
Yesterday
at my Young Horse Day workshop I met a wonderful soul in Boronia, a
young shire mare. I was asked to work with her because she wouldn’t
be caught, especially in the paddock with the other horses.
She would give up in the yard as she knew she was unable to get away,
and her owner saw her as a ‘problem child’, especially when
she kicked out at her when the pressure was on.
I haven’t had that
much to do with the larger draught breeds but when I was a youngster,
I remember being in total awe of the brewery teams of Clydesdales, struck
by their stoic no nonsense natures and work ethic, as well as their
hugeness.
The feeling I got when I
looked at Boronia was of a gentle ‘old’ soul – her
beautiful eyes hid behind a long dark forelock like a shy little girl,
and that’s what she turned out to be.
When I stepped into the yard with her she moved away, so I talked to
the workshop group while I wandered around without looking at her directly
but taking notice of her responses. Without a direct line approach or
thoughts of ‘I’m going to catch you’, she didn’t
feel the need to move far or fast, so with some approach and retreat
I was able to almost get within touching distance – in fact I
was able to stoke her shoulder at one stage but she shied away from
my touch.
I had a bag of treats with
me as her owner admitted to using food to try and ‘bribe’
her into being caught but Boronia became good at snatching a mouthful
from the bucket and moving quickly away. I intended to use the food
as a reward, so to let her know I had some I put a few pellets in my
hand and encouraged her to allow my hand in her space.
She wasn’t that interested in the food – or in touching
my hand, even after tolerating my hand coming in and out of her space,
which alarmed her at first.
So I just kept my body turned slightly away from her and tried making
myself small to see if that attracted her attention. It did and she
dropped her head to my level and relaxed a bit more, content to just
be close to me as long as I didn’t try to touch her.
After a while my knees got
sore from squatting so I slowly stood and rested against the yard rails,
explaining my methods to the people, and with the attention off her
Boronia became curious. We were talking about her past where she was
raised in a large herd on a big property without much attention to anything
more than the basics of handling, and had come to her present owner
very undernourished after a drought sale. Once she was caught she would
allow you to do anything with her and I immediately got the feeling
that she was ‘shutting down’ to cope with the handling she’d
endured – not that it may necessarily have been harsh, but in
her eyes, she was scared and shutting down became her way of coping.
This made her appear to be very quiet but she showed definite signs
of withdrawing when too much pressure was put on her.
I discovered that perhaps
for the first time in her life, Boronia was being allowed to interact
with a person on her terms – she started to sniff me, brushing
her long whiskers against my shirt, then my hand.
She eyed the bale of hay in the next yard, to tell me she’d rather
eat that, so I grabbed a handful and she tucked into it then followed
me around the yard to get more as I moved away from her, and allowed
her to ‘catch me’ – perhaps another first.
Then she got tired of the
hay and was happy just standing near me as I talked some more about
how we could reward horses in different ways, such as being like another
horse, just hanging out or giving them a good scratch.
I reached out to her neck and chest to see if she’d like to be
itched and sure enough, that was her favourite spot. When I stopped,
she carefully moved her big hooves closer and asked for more, inching
forward each time I stopped.
When I decided to finish
the session with her, she was chewing contentedly, with a soft eye and
a smile on her lovely big Shire horse lips.
I invited her owner in to experience Boronia’s acceptance of people
because I knew she’d overcome a big issue – she had never
been given the choice of interacting with a human – it had always
been the human’s idea and forced upon her which was why she didn’t
enjoy being caught.
It was very special to see her owner amazed that she could walk right
up to her ‘Bronnie’ and give her a big friendly rub –
she took off her halter after some encouragement and vowed to spend
more time ‘making deposits into her account’ with her, to
make up for all the ‘withdrawals’ of the past.
The next horse I worked
with was a lovely seven year old paint broodmare who hadn’t yet
been ridden. She was a bit touchy about picking up her hooves and the
workshop participants were keen to see some ‘join up’ and
liberty work.
After explaining that I don’t do the traditional type of ‘join
up’ where you deliberately send the horse away until it asks to
be allowed back in, I introduced myself to the mare and started rubbing
her body to find her favourite itchy spots.
After
a little while she decided eating grass was better and moved off, so
I gently encouraged her to keep moving and waited for her first sign
of aknowledgement which was an eye and an ear focused on me –
I turned away, taking the pressure off her and she willingly came right
into me.
She then stood for more scratching and I worked my way down to her front
leg – but as soon as I’d lifted it a little she hurried
off – she had that choice being at liberty and it’s a wonderful
way to find out what a horse can truly cope with.
Again, I encouraged her to move with the soft swing of the string I
carry and after one trotting circle, she decided she’d rather
be with me.
After that, she didn’t
try to run off again – just moved a little when things got worrying
for her. I was able to pick up all four feet at liberty then taught
her to yield her hindquarters from both a suggestion (looking at them)
and the touch of my hand.
She had some difficulty accepting the yield from her left eye and kept
wanting to turn away and put me in the other eye, but after a few goes
and having the choice to move her feet whenever she was worried, she
could do beautiful yields with my hand on her side, where my leg would
go.
Throughout this interaction
with her I used my ‘clicker’ (my tongue) and treats to reward
her, as food was her favourite motivation. She’d never had any
experience with ‘clicker training’ but caught on right away
without being pushy. This helped her enjoy her interaction with me and
see that playing at liberty can be fun and fruitful.
So I too learned something
from my Young Horse Day – we all have choices and by allowing
the horses theirs, they will show us what’s best for them, so
the more 'tools' (or different ways) for doing things we have, the better.
The students learned from observing that patience can be our greatest
virtue, to take small steps and to consider the horse’s point
of view. There’s always more to learn….
Learning is a never-ending
journey so why not let the journey be the reward – it certainly
is for me, especially when I discover little gems of wisdom from the
horses.
(Photos by Ruth Tanner.)
STARTING
YOUNG HORSES UNDER SADDLE
How to give your young
horse the best start to riding.
by Cynthia Cooper

‘Starting’ a young horse
is a more positive than ‘breaking’ so I will use this term
rather than the traditional ‘breaking-in’ that has become
common language for training a horse to be ridden.
After all, who wants to end up with a ‘broken’ horse? Sadly
many do have their spirit, and sometimes their bodies broken during
a process that has been universally accepted for a very long time.
What I’d like to propose with the
trend now towards more compassion for the horse, that this can include
a totally different approach to ‘starting’ them under saddle.
To begin with, lets forget about the ‘correct age’ for a
horse to be started – traditionally this has been at around 2-3
years although in the racing industry it can be as young as 18 months.
Physically, young horses’ bones and muscles are not strong enough
to carry any weight for any length of time until they are 3-4 years
old, and then they should be carefully built up with short periods of
slow exercise. Harder work and competition shouldn’t be considered
until they are least 4-5 years old and for some slow maturing breeds
like Arabians and warmbloods, 5-6 years is a better time to start.
Realistically, horses can be started under saddle at an older age, although
there is perhaps an optimum time when they can be easily developed mentally
and emotionally and that is usually under the age of maturity (7-8 years).
Ideally,
a young horse is being ‘started’ right from birth and during
the daily handling/checking they should receive, especially for the
first few months of their lives. This will give you a trusting, trainable
and confident young horse who knows how to do all the basics for survival
in a domestic situation such as be easily haltered, led, have hooves
trimmed, be wormed, load /travel on a float/trailer and begin to tie
up for short periods under supervision.
It doesn’t hurt for them to be
‘turned out’ occasionally and have periods of little human
contact providing they are checked and maintained properly, and that
the often negative events of worming, gelding and medical treatment
are not the only contact they have with people – this will definitely
erode any trust you have developed.
So as yearlings and two year olds, it
is possible to prepare them for being ridden by exposing them to all
types of situations, especially if you are not going to be doing the
starting yourself.
Weaning from their dam, especially if done gradually, will help them
learn about separation from their bonded pair or group. But this needs
to be extended for short periods (with company to begin with) so the
youngster learns they can leave the comfort of their own herd and pasture.
This can be done for pleasurable events such as feeding, grooming and
playing, then extended to more challenging things such as going for
walks (led by a person or from another horse), loading and travelling.
Young horses who are taken to shows get
a good education in all these things but even if you don’t show,
you can take your youngster out to visit a friend, to a play day, or
to look around at a small show or event without competing – something
I’d recommend before you do actually compete. Of course, you would
take them with an older calm companion who can help give them confidence
and show them the way.
Then it’s a gradual process to ask them to leave the herd on their
own, beginning as mentioned above and gradually increasing the time
and distance they are comfortable being away from their herd or friend.
If
you’re starting your own young horse, this is still an ideal preparation
so that when it comes time to ride out alone, your horse has confidence
in you and the situations you’re asking them to cope with.
Starting your own horse to be ridden is the ideal situation. You have
a relationship going already – your horse will trust you more
than anyone else so why would you want to send them off to learn new
things from someone they don’t even know?
I think many people lack the confidence to start their own horse, and
that really just indicates they need more horsemanship education themselves.
There are so many good horsemanship programs and clinicians running
‘colt starting’ courses plus easy access to information,
that we can increase our skills for being able to start a young horse.
After all, that’s what you’re going to be doing when the
horse comes back from being started by someone else anyway. If you don’t
have the skills to carry on their work, then you will face problems
and that will most likely instigate either selling the horse or if you
love them enough, learning more yourself anyway.
The most important factor in successfully
starting your own horse is to forget time frames. This is one of the
biggest problems with starting young horses – and why I don’t
agree with short ‘colt starting’ workshops or spectator
events such as ‘Way of the Horse’ where Horsemen are judged
on their starting skills. It puts these often un-prepared young, frightened
horses into overload and you see them ‘shut down’ emotionally
just to be able to cope.
Does it really matter if it takes you
a year to start your horse under saddle? If you’re both progressing
and learning within your comfort zones, then enjoy the journey.
If you want a horse to take out for a ride or to a certain event by
a certain time, go and buy one that is ready for that.
Horses don’t forget what you did with them last – whether
it be a day, a week or a month ago. In fact some good trainers have
realised that giving a horse ‘soaking time’ which could
be for as long as 3 days after learning something new, is the ideal
way for faster progress.
However, I know there will always be
people who want someone else to start their own horse. In that case,
it’s your job to prepare your horse for the situation as I outlined
above. This would include getting them used to being handled by different
people (preferably those with the same philosophies on horses as you),
taking them away for short stays at friend’s places where there’s
no pressure, and having them cope with leaving their herd.
Then it’s a matter of finding the
best person to start your horse so ask around for what others have experienced
then go and see your prospective choices working with other people’s
horses. Some trainers will even travel to your place to work with your
horse, and that is ideal if your philosophies on horses are similar.
At least then you can watch and learn, and intervene on behalf of your
horse if you think its necessary.
Most good young horse starters will allow you or even invite you to
watch them work with your horse because they have yours and the horse’s
best interests at heart.
Listen
to your ‘gut’ or instinctive feelings about the person you
choose to work with. Just because they have a good name in the industry,
doesn’t mean they will align with your beliefs.
Go and watch prospective trainers working with other people’s
horses and get to know their philosophies on horsemanship. Make sure
they ‘walk their talk’! Ask other experienced and respected
horse people who they would get to start their young horse.
Once you have chosen your trainer, communicate
to them what you want – many think the process must be as fast
as possible, but if your horse’s confidence and spirit are important
to you, then you can let them know that time frames can be flexible.
Ask them to allow the horse to have at least a week to settle in to
their new surroundings before they have to cope with training.
Take the feed and hay your horse is used to eating so a gradual transition
can be made to the trainer’s feeds if that’s what will happen.
This will reduce the risk of digestive upsets or even colic. Ensure
your horse has been recently wormed, hooves trimmed and teeth checked.
Only send your horse to be started if they are in good physical health
– there’s no point in the trainer working with a horse that
has physical issues hampering their ability.
Visit your horse as often as you can, especially during training sessions
and to have some riding time under the trainer’s supervision once
your horse is going nicely.
When you get your horse home, its ok
to give them some time off to ‘recover’ from the moving
and adjust back to their home. If you are unsure where to start at home,
then ask the trainer to come and give you some lessons at home on your
horse, or go out for a short ride with you to help give you confidence
that will then transfer to your horse.
If you’re afraid to ride your newly
started horse, then maybe a young horse is not for you. Remember, you
need to be the confident leader to show your young horse the way.
My final word of advice: Give your young horse the best start under
saddle by developing your horsemanship and leadership skills with an
older horse first.
I recommend Parelli level 3 minimum is ideal. To find out what that
involves, go to www.parellli.com and look into the Levels Pathway.
Here is an excellent article that outlines
the negative repercussions that horses possibly suffer at a young age,
or when they are in their teens from being started too young and too
hard.
Why People
Start Horses Too Hard, Too Young By: Laura Phelps-Bell
Cynthia
on Manny with Zach at her Young Horse Starting Course April 2004.
Ask
Cynthia - 'Hoof Handling Problem'
I wonder if you can help me. I have been
practising natural horsemanship for over 5 years and am learning everyday.
I have overcome some huge problems with emotional abused and damaged
horses, but am stuck on the current one. I normally allow a horse to
chill a bit and settle into my routines, whilst doing some fundamentals
of round pen, leading, respect etc and in time they have all become
loveable, well rounded horses that respect me. However this one is in
desperate need of getting his feet trimmed so I cannot afford him the
luxury of "just chillin".
He is a 16hh, 5 yr old Luisitana gelding (cow hocked), backed in Portugal
by tying legs up to the saddle! Have had the chiropractor out which
has made him more comfortable and the dentist has sorted the teeth,
I am trying the methods I have applied before of stick and string all
over, hands all over, working the muscles to soft and asking him to
'give' me the foot. He can now (very different than a week ago when
we started) 'give' me all of his feet and is just, and only just tolerating
me brushing, rubbing and tapping the front feet. Even then, he just
has to snatch them back after a very short time.
Normally, I would hold on and move with him until he can soften, then
release the foot gently onto the floor. Bearing in mind his history
would this be the right thing to do as his fear is of not being able
to get his foot back when he wants it. Also he is so adamant to get
that foot back that it is proving difficult to hold on. He will allow
me to tap, brush and rub his hooves for ages whilst they are planted
on the ground and the holder can even get the head low and ears relaxed
whilst I'm doing this.
I would really appreciate any help and advise you could give. This poor
chap has had such an unfair start in life and deserves to have his feet
trimmed comfortably, before coming to me he had been twitched, sedated
and chiffney bitted to try and achieve this, all to no avail. Jacqui.
Hi Jacqui,
It sounds like you are doing some good things to help horses so well
done for persevering with the difficult ones - I know what that is like
as I have 3 who have come from abusive backgrounds too.
They do eventually trust, but as you know it takes a long time and in
the meantime, you just have to go with where the horse is mentally.
If I were in your position, I wouldn't worry about your gelding having
to take his feet back - it sounds like he is trying really hard and
that is all you can ask of him right now or risk the trust you have
built so far.
Think of it like trailer loading a scared horse - we allow them to come
out of the trailer as often as they like but then ask them to go back
on until they can trust enough to stay there.
It can be the same with the hooves - let him have the feet back as often
as he needs so he trusts that he can always be safe with you, but ask
for them back again and don't let it bother you too much.
If you 'go with' a horse like this rather than try to hold on and 'stay
with' him, you will find that he makes faster progress.
I know this makes it hard to trim but doing a little without having
to put the leg between yours is safer and less traumatic for him.
Also, just do a little bit on each hoof at a time - don't try to get
all 4 hooves trimmed in one session - he won't die from having bad feet
or if his hooves are different lengths for a day or so - although you
should at least make sure each individual hoof is kept in balance.
You might start with just doing one front hoof the first day or cleaning
out and scraping away dead sole on each front hoof on the first day
then using the nippers to cut the wall on the second day and rasping
on the third.
Try to think of the trimming as part of his training rather than the
end product that has to be achieved right now.
There are a couple of other things you could try to help him be braver
- by lifting his legs with a rope around the pastern you can stay with
him if he wants to put the foot down without him feeling too trapped
but also letting him know that he is not able to completely get away
from some pressure.
Get to where you can lift the leg in a rhythm first with him remaining
relaxed before you ask for him to hold it up for any length of time.
Another tool I would also try is 'clicker training' where you use a
positive reward for holding the leg up for increasingly longer periods
of time. If you haven't had much experience with this, read Alexandra
Kurland's web site on Clicker training http://www.theclickercenter.com/guide/index.html
to get the basics going.
I've found this to be a real help with very scared horses as they have
rarely had positive reinforcement before.